பரத்வாஜ் ரங்கனின் விமர்சனத்துக்கு எழுதிய மறுமொழியின் பிரதி இங்கே சேமிப்புக்காக
Honest , unbiased review. Thanks Baradwaj.
Superstar’s creative inputs to his own films have always remained minimal, in the sense that, SS belives in the maker and submits himself to the director completely, unlike kamalhassan. Kamalhassan would think twice before he utters something like ‘ sivajiyum nAnE, mgr-um nAne‘ or even naan rajini maathiri style paNNap pOREn in place of thalaivar’s naan kamalhassan maathiri colour- a maaRap pORen.
With this kind of an actor who comes with an electrifying screen presence and an enviable technical crew, we expect Shankar to deliver a gripping story like mudhalvan or even indhiyan.. Shankar had this magical skill of making unbelievable stories from funny ideas like oru nAL muthalvan to interesting movies. but… ingga enna nadakkuthu?.
Though as thalaivar’s fan i enjoyed the movie thoroughly, as a movie buff i was totally dissppointed with the story line and absurd sequences like the one in which thalaivar threatens auditors to disclose their client’s information. C’mon.. how illogical can shankar or even sujatha get more?
Regarding the comedy in the first half, i’m not surprised at your reaction. From what i have read ( in blogs & MSM), the reactions are mixed . While a group came out from the auditorium severly injured after falling from their seats laughing, the other group reportedly went bald, scratching their heads at regular intervals. I belonged to the first category.
Weak storyline, incohesive screenplay, shortage of original ideas, unwanted extravagance in songs ithu ellaathaiyum
meeRi, if this movie had kept me engrossed for the whole 190 minutes… its because of the one and only Super Star.